Skip to content

an independent, Jewish entity

There has never been an independent, Jewish entity that ruled over the entirety of the region claimed by Zionists as "Israel." The closest was ~50 years of the Hasmonean dynasty, which never extended south of Beersheba, between the suzerainty of the Seleucid and Roman empires. https://t.co/D3tPc1FHYp If we want to be VERY generous with our definitions, there was a small, centrally-organized Hebrew polity -- the Kingdom of Judah -- extending between Jerusalem and Beersheba, that was largely independent for about 2 centuries, before being subsumed into Neo-Assyria. For those keeping score, there was a maximum of about 250 years of an independent Jewish state in Palestine over the past 3,000 years, most of which covered only a tiny portion of the region, none of which covered all of it, and none of which was in the past 2,000 years.